for our e-mail list for updates and socially responsible
1015 18th St. NW
Washington, DC 20036
Tel: 202 429-8900
Fax: 202 429-8905
Nanotechnology The Next Revolution
In a New York Times article from September 2003,
the authors presented the idea of a "Nano Space Elevator"
that would allow cheaper, faster and safer trips to space using
nanotechnology. In 2003, the U.S. government spent $774 billion
on the National
Nanotechnology Initiative. Hundreds of new companies have emerged
carrying the word "nano" in their name. The newest pants
from Eddie Bauer are called "nanopants" and are promised
to be both wrinkle and stain resistant. But what is "nanotechnology"?
What implications evolve from its development? Where do the dangers
lie? What will the effects on the society be?
There are almost as many definitions of nanotechnology as there
are institutions dealing with it. In general, however, a distinction
is made between two main types of nanotechnology. The National Science
Foundation (NSF), most of the US government, and many others define
nanotechnology as a "set
of tools, techniques and unique applications involving the structure
and composition of materials on a nanoscale." ("Nano"
stands for "nanometer" which is a billionth of a meter.)
The original definition that came from Richard Feynman in 1959 and
Eric K. Drexler in 1986, on the other hand, relates to molecular
nanotechnology (MNT) and describes a manufacturing method - "the
ability to fabricate a wide variety of complex parts with molecular
precision" (Chris Phoenix, CRN). Basically, the idea is to
be able to build with every molecule in its specified place, much
like using LEGO pieces, instead of manufacturing a product from
other materials. As soon as personal assemblers or even "nanofactories"
are developed, products can be assembled much cheaper and faster
than they are now. Although there are not yet many practical applications
of MNT, there are several products that already contain materials
on the nano-scale, such as in tennis rackets, car parts and semi-conductors.
Despite the fact that MNT does not typically receive as much funding
technologies," it is MNT that, as soon as it has advanced
far enough, will revolutionize technology and society in general.
Nanotechnology will be omnipresent in everyday life, changing essential
aspects of society through its potential effects on developing countries,
the environment, medicine and the military.
The effects on developing countries could be tremendous. Clean and
abundant energy, medical diagnostics and nanotech water filtration
devices would be basic improvements for people in developing countries.
According to Eric Werwa, legislative assistant to Congressman Michael
Honda, developing countries could compete more easily using nanotech
than they do at present, as this "new way of manufacturing
[would] not require large factories." But Chris Phoenix, Director
of Research and Co-Founder of the Center for Responsible Nanotechnology
(CRN) doubts that developing countries will be allowed access to
this technology, as it will be seen as too dangerous to "afford
the possibility of foreign economic competition." Therefore,
the question is how to assure that developing countries will benefit
more from the nanotechnology revolution than they did from the information
Nanotechnology will also affect the environment. Some people say
that in being able to produce more efficient products, wasting less
material, and developing environmental remediation techniques such
as "oil-eating nanobots," (see movie "Agent Cody
Banks") nanotechnology could be helpful. Others, such as the
Action Group on Erosion, Technology and Concentration (ETC Group),
fear that small nanoparticles will contaminate food and drinking
water and ask governments to halt development of nanotechnology.
Still others, like Mr. Phoenix, say that although we will be able
to produce and live more efficiently, we will want to use more of
it. "So more than ever, it will be our choice whether to preserve
the environment or trample it."
In the field of medicine, major progress will be made using nanotechnology.
Small machines or robots could be implanted in humans to cure all
kinds of diseases. Furthermore, physiological immortality is thinkable
in the long run, through different methods of cell repair. Having
the ability to cure more diseases is almost indubitably seen as
a good thing. However, a technology that enables humans to live
forever raises ethical questions like the one Mr. Werwa asks: "Do
we really want a world where those who can afford the technology
can live forever and be always healthy while those who are less
fortunate financially cannot enjoy such benefits?" In addition,
is it realistic to believe that if the technology existed it would
be possible to prevent people from using it?
To estimate the anticipated effect of nanotechnology on military
devices, one has only to look at last year's US government
spending on nanotechnology. In 2003, almost one-third of the money
spent by President Bush's National Nanotechnology Initiative
went to the Department of Defense.1 In the short term, the better
protection of soldiers through smaller, stronger and more efficient
devices built with nanotechnology (for example, better armored uniforms,
equipped with sensors to monitor the soldier's health) is
the most important goal. But in the long run, Phoenix says, "MNT
will be an incredible force multiplier," meaning that new,
extremely powerful weapons could be developed. A new arms race,
even a pre-emptive strike by the country that develops the first
"nano-bomb," is a possible scenario.
Nanotechnology will have a tremendous impact on society. It will
not only produce a new "nanotech industry," but will also
have impacts on all existing technologies, making them both more
efficient and cheaper. There will be as many great benefits (cleaner
energy, improved health, etc.) as there will be dangers from misuse
(new, stronger weapons, ecological dangers, etc.). In addition,
new ethical and moral issues, such as immortality and controlling
access, will have to be discussed openly to prepare for nanotechnology's
This brief includes interviews with experts and four articles that
will present the different perspectives on this issue, as well as
three ethical questions that exhibit the scope of this debate. Finally,
a list of suggested books, web sites, articles, speakers and movies
provide further research on the subject area.
Nikos Nikolidakis, University of Free Berlin, 2003 Fall Intern